The Rise of the Meritocracy
A discussion of the Rise of the Meritocracy on the sixtieth birthday of the book by Michael Young
Toby Young, the journalist and educational reformer, who is the son of Lord Young, will deliver a lecture on the book.
The discussion between Toby Young and Enikő Bollobás, prominent Hungarian literature scholar and former diplomat will be moderated by Péter Ákos Bod.
Meritocracy is a word used to describe a social system in which those who hold leadership positions in government, business, and social, cultural and educational institutions do so deservedly because they have risen by ability and shown potential for achievement. The word is generally seen as a favorable one by people across the political spectrum in advanced countries. Developing nations too are often urged to adopt more meritocratic systems of promotion as opposed to reliance on family connections, ‘clientelist’ networks, or corrupt cronyism. One might say that meritocracy has conquered the world.
But is this general approval deserved? The original usage of the word was a hostile one. It was coined in the 1958 satirical novel, The Rise of the Meritocracy, by Michael Young, a distinguished British social scientist whose achievements included writing the 1945 Labour party election manifesto and establishing the UK Social Science Research Council.
Lord Young, as he later became, rooted this new social class in the definition of merit as Ability + Effort = Merit. A meritocrat was someone who might come from any social background but whose innate ability had been detected through IQ tests and who had then been given a fast-track education to the top of whatever profession seemed to suit him. In the logic of meritocracy his success was seen as just, at least by him and his fellow-meritocrats.
What, however, of those whose lesser abilities consigned them to lower positions and a less prosperous life? Writing from the perspective of 2033, Young’s fictional narrator not only describes how a fully-fledged meritocracy had been built over the previous seventy years but also reported worrying signs that it was increasingly resisted from below by those shunted into lower occupations. He mentions riots, and a footnote reveals that he was killed in the disturbances of 2033.
Not all of Young’s predictions have come to pass—his book is a satire, after all, and a very entertaining one—but some now look prescient. We are aware, for instance, of “cognitive elites” in modern societies who live lives increasingly separate from those of other citizens. The rise of populist parties in peaceful electoral rebellions against European and (in the UK, Remainer) technocratic elites has faint echoes of the closing pages of the book. Meritocracy is a topic that suddenly seems very topical.
Nigel Farage - Danube Dialogues by Danube InstitutePast Events
John O’Sullivan interviewed Nigel Farage, well known broadcaster and journalist, founder of the Brexit Party, and one of the most prominent figures behind Britain leaving the European Union.
Melanie Phillips - Lockdown Diaries by Danube InstitutePast Events
In this episode of the Lockdown Diaries, John O’Sullivan, president of the Danube Institute in Budapest interviews Melanie Phillips, British journalist, author, public commentator, currently living in
Rich Lowry - Lockdown Diaries by Danube InstitutePast Events
In this episode of Lockdown Diaries John O’Sullivan, the president of the Danube Institute in Budapest interviews Richard Lowry, editor-in-chief of the US-based National Review.
Lockdown Diaries: John Fund on current political issues of the USPast Events
Newly invented video series by Danube Institute, Lockdown Diaries presents: Talking with John Fund, the American commentator, columnist, author.
Lockdown Diaries: Alberto Mingardi talks about the crisis caused by coronavirusPast Events
John O’Sullivan, President of The Danube Institute took a deep interview with Alberto Mingardi, executive director of Istituto Bruno Leoni.
Lockdown Diaries with Douglas Murray, bestselling authorPast Events
President of Danube Institute John O'Sullivan talks about Douglas Murray's latest book, 'The Madness of Crowds: Gender Race and Identity'.
2nd International Conference on Christian Persecution, Nov 26 2019Videos
Danube Institute Side Event: Helping the Persecuted: NGOs Challenge Global Agencies and Corporations.
Assessment of the 2019 Local Elections in Hungary - The VideoVideos
With Boris Kálnoky, Balázs Orbán, and Zoltán Pogátsa
MAPH-1067 Budapest, Eötvös u. 24.
Phone: +36 1 269 1041
Switch to a larger map